Two and a half years of label rejections, a producer who thought it was a Springsteen parody, and a baseball announcer who claims he didn't know what he was really narrating — the teenage rock opera that became one of the best-selling albums ever made.
A Wagnerian teenage crash-and-burn opera that took two and a half years and dozens of rejections to find a label, produced by a man who thought he was recording a Springsteen parody. It became one of the best-selling albums ever made, and it did it slowly — spending 522 weeks on the UK chart, the fourth-longest run in that chart's history.
Meat Loaf's debut, written entirely by Jim Steinman and produced by Todd Rundgren, was rejected by nearly every label in America for two and a half years before Cleveland International's Steve Popovich signed it on the strength of a spoken-word intro. It then took roughly two more years to become a hit — and forty-nine years later it still hasn't stopped selling.
Before it was an album, Bat Out of Hell was a stage musical nobody wanted to fund. Jim Steinman had been building the same magnum opus in different costumes since college — a 1968 show called The Dream Engine, then a 1974 workshop piece called Neverland, a 'futuristic rock version' of Peter Pan that finally got a full staging at the Kennedy Center in 1977. Steinman and Meat Loaf, touring together in a National Lampoon revue, decided three of Neverland's songs — 'Bat Out of Hell,' 'Heaven Can Wait' and a number then called 'The Formation of the Pack' — were exceptional enough to build a seven-song record around.
What followed, by Meat Loaf's own account, was two and a half years of the most brutal rejection either man ever experienced. They performed the songs live for label after label — Steinman on piano, Meat Loaf singing, Ellen Foley sometimes joining for 'Paradise' — and were turned down by all of them. His manager, David Sonenberg, joked that new record companies seemed to be forming just so they'd have someone new to reject the album. The low point was Clive Davis at CBS, who told them 'actors don't make records' and dressed down Steinman's songwriting in front of him — 'Do you know how to write a song? ... You don't know how.' Meat Loaf says he screamed obscenities up from the street outside Davis's building afterward. Steinman just laughed it off.
The producer who finally said yes did so partly as a joke. Todd Rundgren, coming off his work with his own band Utopia, thought the songs — over-the-top, operatic, structurally nothing like a normal rock record — were a deliberate parody of Bruce Springsteen. 'I thought it was a parody... this big, fat, operatic guy doing totally over-the-top, over-wrought, drawn-out songs... Bruce Springsteen squared,' he said years later. 'I can't believe the world took it seriously.' Parody or not, he loved it enough to produce it, and when the label deal he'd arranged through RCA turned out not to actually exist, Rundgren paid for the sessions out of his own pocket.
Recording ran through 1975 and 1976 across four studios — Bearsville and Utopia Sound in upstate New York, The Hit Factory in Manhattan, House of Music in New Jersey — with a band built from two overlapping camps that gave the record its exact, argued-over sound. Rundgren's own group Utopia supplied Kasim Sulton on bass, Roger Powell on synthesizer and Willie Wilcox on drums for most of the album; two members of Bruce Springsteen's E Street Band, pianist Roy Bittan and drummer Max Weinberg, played on three tracks including the title cut. Rundgren himself played most of the guitars, including the wailing 'motorcycle solo' that opens the record. Steinman, who could hear every part in his head but couldn't orchestrate them, hummed his arrangements at Rundgren, who built them out.
It is genuinely true that Steinman denies modelling the record on Springsteen directly — 'Springsteen was more an inspiration than an influence,' he said, calling the comparison 'puzzling, musically.' It's also true that almost nobody who hears 'Bat Out of Hell' or 'You Took the Words Right Out of My Mouth' — the latter built on the same charging Who chords as 'Baba O'Riley,' filtered through a Phil Spector Wall of Sound melody — believes him without a raised eyebrow, and that having two of Springsteen's own musicians in the room only sharpened the comparison. Steinman's real reference points were Spector, The Who and his own decade of unproduced musical-theatre ambition; the Springsteen echo is a coincidence of era and geography that happens to be very loud.
Still without a real deal, the album found a home through another E Street connection: Steven Van Zandt and manager David Sonenberg steered it to Cleveland International Records, a small Epic-distributed label run by Steve Popovich. Popovich signed the record after hearing nothing more than the spoken-word intro to 'You Took the Words Right Out of My Mouth' — a two-minute piece with roots in a musical Steinman had shelved a decade earlier. Even after signing, Epic's own staff mostly hated it; Popovich spent the better part of a year fighting his own company's indifference just to get it played.
The album that resulted is, structurally, a rock opera pretending to be a rock record: seven songs, one of them a three-part, eight-and-a-half-minute suite with a Yankees announcer doing baseball-as-sex play-by-play in the middle of it, none of them shorter than four minutes, all of them staged like the biggest moment of somebody's teenage life. Dave Marsh's original Rolling Stone review called the songs 'entirely mannered and derivative' and said the 'principals have some growing to do' — a verdict that reads, in hindsight, like someone grading a firework display for structural engineering. It missed the point on purpose: nothing about Bat Out of Hell was supposed to be tasteful. It was supposed to be the most extreme version of every feeling a seventeen-year-old has ever had, played at the largest possible scale, and on that metric it has never really been matched.
It also, notoriously, took its time. British and Australian audiences caught on first, largely off a BBC screening of the band performing the nine-minute title track on The Old Grey Whistle Test — a clip so popular it was re-aired the following week. In North America, Popovich built the record market by market, city by city, for over a year before it broke nationally. By the time it stopped selling — which, forty-nine years on, it still hasn't, entirely — it had gone 14× Platinum in the US, become Australia's best-selling album of all time, and set a UK chart-longevity record that Fleetwood Mac, Pink Floyd and Oasis are the only studio albums to beat. Steinman, reflecting on it in 1993, put it best: 'It's timeless in that it didn't fit into any trend... You could release that record at any time and it would be out of place.'
This isn't a scarcity story the way most 1970s rock classics are — Bat Out of Hell sold in the tens of millions, and clean original US (PE 34974) and UK (EPC 82419) stereo pressings turn up constantly and cheaply. The genuine grail here is the format novelty: the 1977 US 'Special Limited Picture Edition' picture disc (E99 34974), issued in a die-cut cover, which trades real scarcity for explicitly worse sound — Epic's own sleeve notes warned buyers it would generate audible surface noise. It's the pressing collectors chase precisely because almost nobody bought it to actually listen to.
© The Lead-In · an independent, reader-supported music publication.
